Why is Carlos Poor?

By Jeff Palmer, CEO on March 19, 2018 | Print

THE FACTS

Let me introduce you to my friend Carlos. Carlos is a subsistence farmer in a developing country. Everything his family eats or sells comes from what they can produce on their two-acre plot of land (about the size of a large home lot in the USA). When necessary, Carlos will also take on temporary jobs.

Carlita, his wife, works hard as well. Not only does she do all the housework, take care of their four children, and work with Carlos on their farm to provide for their family, she also sews and does some odd jobs around the community to bring in some extra income as well.

Carlos and Carlita work hard. However, their land is on the mountainside and sloping. They can’t afford the really good lowland farms where the better crops are grown. They built their two-roomed bamboo/wood framed home with the things they grew and harvested from their own farm. Simple, but enough for their family of six. They love their children and do all they can to make sure they can go to school and get an education. They believe education is an opportunity for their children to have a better life.

THE PERCEPTION

If you and I (as outsiders) were to visit Carlos and his family, our initial reaction would probably be that this family (like many others) lives on the edge of poverty. They have food and income in good times, but in times of stress (drought, major sickness to a family member, etc.), things can be hard–even desperate. They have survived this way for years. In fact, their parents and grandparents survived this way as well. We would probably (at best) call them “working poor.”

Myers’ Breakdown

So why is Carlos poor? As discussed in our previous blog post, Brent Myers has developed various categories that explain the reasons why poverty exists and persists.

  • Lack of resources: We might conclude that Carlos is poor because he doesn’t have enough resources to start with. Carlos was born into a family/nation that just doesn’t have enough resources to go around. This creates a poverty trap of which there is very little hope of escaping.
  • Poor Social Structure: We might also conclude that poor social structure or support is to blame. In other words, the government of his country doesn’t care or is in some way inadequate to address poverty.
  • Once Poor, Always Poor: We might even think that Carlos, Carlita, and their neighbors simply accept that they are and always will be poor. In the early days of development theory, there were several western development economists who deduced that the western mindset and work ethic were superior to those of the rest of the world and was the primary factor of wealth versus poverty.
  • Deficiencies…and more: Maybe we would conclude that Carlos and his family are poor because of some mental deficiency (Myers’ category). Lack of education opportunities, no access to technology, etc., would be the main reason for their poverty.

Or maybe, we would assume that Carlos’ poverty is due to sin and judgement on his community/country.

As you can see, from an outsider’s perspective, we could jump to any of a number of conclusions or reasons as to why we think Carlos is poor.

But I wonder what Carlos would say (if we took time to ask him)…

Other posts in this series:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *